The “Substantialy Contributing” Test: Insurance Companies Don’t Always Win

Substantialy Contributing Test AD&D Claims

In an earlier post, we took a first look at how courts treat pre-existing medical conditions when considering whether to award Accidental Death & Dismemberment (AD&D) benefits to plaintiffs. We pointed out that different courts have treated this question differently. Some will disqualify a plaintiff from benefits only if the pre-existing condition “directly and independently of all other causes” caused a death or dismemberment. Other courts will disqualify one from benefits if the pre-existing condition “substantially contributed” to the loss. The Eleventh Circuit Federal Appeals Court which governs Florida follows the “substantially contributed” test. Our first article might lead one to believe that Florida policyholders have long-shot odds of winning their AD&D case. This is not true. AD&D claimants do have a fighting chance as long as they retain experienced counsel familiar with case law in this specialized area.

Take for example the decision in Dowdy v. MetLife, a Ninth Circuit Court case, that has applicability in Florida based on its reasoning. The plaintiff in Dowdy was severely injured in a car accident and when persistent infections set in his left leg was ultimately amputated below the knee. His insurance company denied AD&D insurance benefits claiming that pre-existing diabetes substantially caused or contributed to the loss of limb. The District Court agreed with the carrier and denied benefits but the Appeals Court reversed and awarded those benefits finding that the insurance company fell short of sufficient proof. Some of the Court’s observations in making that decision would undoubtedly help any plaintiff in a similar situation. For instance, the Court found that a pre-existing condition must be more than merely a contributing factor to constitute being a “substantial contributing factor”. Moreover, the Court noted that a “pre-disposition” to injury alone, whether it results from congenital weakness or from previous illness or injury, does not necessarily amount to a substantial contributing cause.

Specifically, in the Dowdy case, the Court noted that a deep leg infection was “related to the original injury” and that the evidence failed to show that diabetes was a substantial contributing factor. The Court ruled in the Plaintiff’s favor.

The lesson to be learned in these and other cases is this: don’t try to do this yourself. You need to retain an attorney familiar with the standards of proof and case law governing AD&D cases. Similarly, you shouldn’t just hire any attorney. In an age of specialization AD&D law is its own body of law. Find an attorney with AD&D expertise and experience.

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on google
Google+
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on pinterest
Pinterest

1,591 thoughts on “The “Substantialy Contributing” Test: Insurance Companies Don’t Always Win

  1. I wish to point out my love for your kind-heartedness giving support to folks who should have guidance on your issue. Your very own commitment to getting the solution up and down became incredibly beneficial and have consistently made regular people much like me to get to their aims. Your amazing interesting guidelines denotes a great deal a person like me and much more to my office colleagues. Thank you; from everyone of us. Wendie Elwin Fruin

  2. The road seemed to stretch on endlessly before us, but Alexis assured me that our journey was near an end. We’d turn before long into thick woods and travel through narrow, winding roads until we reached her family’s cabin. I had no choice but to trust her as GPS had given out nearly 20 minutes ago.

    “There’s good wifi and okay reception at the cabin,” she’d told me, “but you can’t get there unless you know the way.”

    So here I was, driving alone in the middle of god knows where with a girl who was my student just a couple of weeks ago. Her and her four best friends had been together from first grade all the way through high school and now they had graduated with very different futures ahead of them. They had decided to kick off “the best summer ever” with a week long stay at Alexis’s family cabin. Alexis and I were heading up before everyone else, the four other girls and four guys.

  3. The road seemed to stretch on endlessly before us, but Alexis assured me that our journey was near an end. We’d turn before long into thick woods and travel through narrow, winding roads until we reached her family’s cabin. I had no choice but to trust her as GPS had given out nearly 20 minutes ago.

    “There’s good wifi and okay reception at the cabin,” she’d told me, “but you can’t get there unless you know the way.”
    https://medium.com/@sophiesconner/third-time-is-a-charm-pt-02-329226c71361
    So here I was, driving alone in the middle of god knows where with a girl who was my student just a couple of weeks ago. Her and her four best friends had been together from first grade all the way through high school and now they had graduated with very different futures ahead of them. They had decided to kick off “the best summer ever” with a week long stay at Alexis’s family cabin. Alexis and I were heading up before everyone else, the four other girls and four guys.

  4. Одновременно с этим существует и другая сторона формирования и организации высказывания.

  5. Одновременно с этим существует и другая сторона формирования и организации высказывания.

  6. The road seemed to stretch on endlessly before us, but Alexis assured me that our journey was near an end. We’d turn before long into thick woods and travel through narrow, winding roads until we reached her family’s cabin. I had no choice but to trust her as GPS had given out nearly 20 minutes ago.

    “There’s good wifi and okay reception at the cabin,” she’d told me, “but you can’t get there unless you know the way.”
    https://notepin.co/shared/xtyzhef
    So here I was, driving alone in the middle of god knows where with a girl who was my student just a couple of weeks ago. Her and her four best friends had been together from first grade all the way through high school and now they had graduated with very different futures ahead of them. They had decided to kick off “the best summer ever” with a week long stay at Alexis’s family cabin. Alexis and I were heading up before everyone else, the four other girls and four guys.

  7. The road seemed to stretch on endlessly before us, but Alexis assured me that our journey was near an end. We’d turn before long into thick woods and travel through narrow, winding roads until we reached her family’s cabin. I had no choice but to trust her as GPS had given out nearly 20 minutes ago.

    “There’s good wifi and okay reception at the cabin,” she’d told me, “but you can’t get there unless you know the way.”
    https://telegra.ph/Becoming-Samantha-10-13
    So here I was, driving alone in the middle of god knows where with a girl who was my student just a couple of weeks ago. Her and her four best friends had been together from first grade all the way through high school and now they had graduated with very different futures ahead of them. They had decided to kick off “the best summer ever” with a week long stay at Alexis’s family cabin. Alexis and I were heading up before everyone else, the four other girls and four guys.

  8. The road seemed to stretch on endlessly before us, but Alexis assured me that our journey was near an end. We’d turn before long into thick woods and travel through narrow, winding roads until we reached her family’s cabin. I had no choice but to trust her as GPS had given out nearly 20 minutes ago.

    “There’s good wifi and okay reception at the cabin,” she’d told me, “but you can’t get there unless you know the way.”
    https://rentry.co/hh9po
    So here I was, driving alone in the middle of god knows where with a girl who was my student just a couple of weeks ago. Her and her four best friends had been together from first grade all the way through high school and now they had graduated with very different futures ahead of them. They had decided to kick off “the best summer ever” with a week long stay at Alexis’s family cabin. Alexis and I were heading up before everyone else, the four other girls and four guys.

  9. Подключение к Интернету могут обеспечить довольно большое наличность портативных девайсов благодаря наличию в устройстве соответствующего специального разъёма чтобы карты связи оператора. Присутствие этом возникают некоторые неудобства в применении, если приходится около каждое портативное детище сам избирать чтобы каждого из них SIM-карту с подходящим тарифным планом или вертеть ее с одного приспособления на другое. В этом в случае ради эффективности использования времени и средств несравненно лучше обеспечить единое интернет-соединение, присутствие котором однако устройства будут иметь высокоскоростное подключение.

    По этой причине портативные 3G/4G модемы и мобильные рутеры станут лучшей альтернативой для беспроводного подключения к Всемирной паутине.

    Подключить беспроводной интернет ради 1 гривну >>

    3G USB-модем: описание характеристик и достоинств

    3G USB-модем – это девайс чтобы обеспечения доступа к Интернету для высокой пропускной способности. Сообразно внешнему виду 3G USB-модемы выглядят как flash-накопители. Преимуществом модемного подключения является необходимость использования внешней антенны в регионах с низким уровнем приема цифрового сигнала. Значительную часть времени 3G USB-модем находится в комплекте с компьютером либо ноутбуком. Только и в других случаях, модемы поставляются с соответствующим драйвером.

    Использование модема будет простое: воеже кончаться в Интернет, надо подключить его к ПК, затем автоматический установить драйвер, затем чего установить дистанционное соединение, конец! 3G USB модемы позволительно задействовать в качестве резервного доступа к домашней сети. Чтобы этого необходимо подключить USB-модем к настольному маршрутизатору и выполнить соответствующие настройки. USB 3G модем также может услуживать для связи путем USB-кабель с графическими планшетами. Впрочем не однако пользователи устройств с Android могут скрываться готовы к работе с 3G USB-модемом.

    Также USB-модем применяют, когда надо подключить к интернет несколько устройств.

  10. The road seemed to stretch on endlessly before us, but Alexis assured me that our journey was near an end. We’d turn before long into thick woods and travel through narrow, winding roads until we reached her family’s cabin. I had no choice but to trust her as GPS had given out nearly 20 minutes ago.

    “There’s good wifi and okay reception at the cabin,” she’d told me, “but you can’t get there unless you know the way.”
    https://txt.fyi/-/2138/4fd61412/
    So here I was, driving alone in the middle of god knows where with a girl who was my student just a couple of weeks ago. Her and her four best friends had been together from first grade all the way through high school and now they had graduated with very different futures ahead of them. They had decided to kick off “the best summer ever” with a week long stay at Alexis’s family cabin. Alexis and I were heading up before everyone else, the four other girls and four guys.

  11. Собрание Бундеслиги для ARD – это классическое объяснение футбольных событий для радио. В новом сезоне он впервые будет выходить в эфир в ход 90 минут, об этом сообщает ресурс Netgate. Это отрывок молодежного продвижения телерадиовещательной сети.

    Каждую субботу в среднем 7,4 миллиона прислуга слушают Бундеслигу на радиостанциях ARD, и в будущем сезоне в связи с новыми правами на аудиоматериалы это сходство значительно возрастет. “Мы совершенствуем сервис и готовы считать полные отчеты обо всех матчах 1-й и 2-й Бундеслиги”, – сказал Маркус Теппер в интервью Deutsche Presse-Agentur. Спортивный координатор радио ARD также обнародовал 90-минутную конференцию сообразно субботам во другой половине дня.

    Всетаки этот масштабный футбольный часть будет звучать не на классическом FM-радио, а в эфире различных онлайн-сервисов, таких только фирменные приложения и веб-сайты станций. “Цель заключается в книга, воеже нас было свободно встречать и свободно использовать”, – объявил Теппер.
    Почему беспричинно поступает общественный вещатель? “АРД стремится к расширению своего цифрового портфеля, – пояснил Теппер. “Это инвестиции в будущее”. И: “Мы хотим привлечь новых участников и слушателей с через нового предложения”.

    Больше онлайн – для молодой аудитории

    Эта политика также включает в себя права для видеоклипы сообразно утрам в понедельник, которые также были приобретены недавно и которые начальник ARD Часть Бухроу назвал “огромной возможностью”, если приобретал лицензии прошлым летом. ARD хочет “делать больше онлайн чтобы более молоденький аудитории”, – сказал Бухров. До конца текущего сезона ARD владеет как правами для аудиовещание своих радиостанций чтобы классического приема в FM-диапазоне. Впрочем в июне прошлого года вещательная сеть также приобрела для аукционе права на аудиовещание в Интернете. “Мы недолго радовались, а после приступили к работе”, – сообщил Теппер.

    Этот часть прав изменился вдруг никакой противоположный после последние годы. Потом старта в 2008 году на 90elf, аудиорепортажи прежде были доступны на сайте divertissement1.fm, а теперь до конца текущего сезона – для Amazon “Prime Music”. Футбольные репортажи сегодня позволительно прислушиваться даром на сайте розничного гиганта, но они прерываются рекламой.